Paper evaluation sheet

First name

Last name

Your Email

paper number (required)
GEM&L 2020/2021

OVERALL REVIEW

Appropriateness of the topic for the Gem&L workshop in general
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

Quality of theoretical/conceptual development
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

Appropriateness and soundness of research methodology
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

Originality and creativity of ideas
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

Organization and clarity of paper
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

Overall contribution to advancing research/practice
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

General attractiveness of paper for academics in the field
---PoorMarginalAcceptableGoodExcellent

FINAL RECOMMENDATION

I recommend this paper for the best paper or best doctoral paper award.

REVIEWER'S COMMENTS

Suggestions which would improve the quality of the paper (300-400 words) (required)